Igor Thiago vs Evanilson vs Calvert-Lewin: which FPL forward fits your team?
The third forward position can make or break a balanced FPL squad. Igor Thiago, Evanilson and Dominic Calvert-Lewin offer different combinations of cost, goal threat and fixture appeal. Choosing the best one requires more than checking last weekend’s score.
The official FPL Scout selected Thiago for GW8 because Brentford visit Hull, while its expert panel called Calvert-Lewin an attractive value option thanks to starting security, penalties and non-penalty xG. Those are useful indicators, but an individual manager must also consider their squad's available money and the weeks after GW8.
Comparison snapshot: 22 October research
| Factor | Igor Thiago | Evanilson | Calvert-Lewin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Club | Brentford | Bournemouth | Leeds |
| Approx. reported FPL price | £7.8m | £6.1m | £6.1m after 22 Oct rise |
| Main case | Brentford focal point, appealing GW8 matchup | Lower-cost attacking slot, fixtures to examine | Penalty role and underlying goal threat |
| Main question | Is the premium over £6m forwards worth it? | Is his minutes/shot volume reliable enough? | Are penalties and playing time sustainable? |
Price check: reported values can change overnight. Use the live comparison rather than assuming these remain exact.
Latest FPL news
Why Igor Thiago may be worth paying for
Brentford's visit to Hull in GW8 offers a favourable opportunity. An attacker regularly central to his team's penalty-box actions can justify a higher price, particularly when he plays most league minutes. But paying extra for a striker works only when it does not force a weaker midfield or a non-playing defensive bench.
Why Evanilson belongs in the conversation
Evanilson is a different sort of move: an affordable forward who may let you strengthen another position. Review the quality and frequency of his chances, his place in Bournemouth’s attack and their upcoming schedule. A low price does not help if he regularly loses minutes or has few penalty-area touches.
Why Calvert-Lewin stands out
The Premier League's expert assessment highlights his penalty duty, expected minutes and strong non-penalty expected goals relative to João Pedro. These factors make him a genuine candidate rather than merely a cheap enabler. A penalty-taker still needs enough open-play chances to remain a good option if spot-kicks do not arrive.
The correct comparison: forward plus freed budget
Suppose choosing one of the two cheaper forwards instead of Thiago saves about £1.7m. The proper comparison is not Thiago vs Calvert-Lewin. It is Thiago plus your existing midfielder versus Calvert-Lewin plus the midfielder you can upgrade. Sometimes the second combination has better projected points even when Thiago is the stronger individual forward.
Test both paths in OneFPL Transfer Planner. Include the next four Gameweeks, the possibility of a one-match suspension or injury, and the points cost of any second transfer.
Who should you buy?
- Thiago: for managers prioritising immediate Brentford goal threat and able to afford the upgrade.
- Calvert-Lewin: for a more economical attacking role with penalty upside.
- Evanilson: for managers prioritising budget flexibility who are comfortable with his current minutes and fixtures.
There is no automatic winner for every squad. Revisit the decision after GW8 minutes and any new injury news.
Sources and further reading
- Premier League Scout Selection GW8
- Premier League FPL GW8 expert panel
- Premier League FPL price changes, 22 October
- Official FPL Fixture Difficulty Rating
---
Editorial correction — 26 October 2026: Forward comparison after GW8
Evanilson scored in Bournemouth’s 3–0 win at Manchester United, while Brentford drew 1–1 at Hull. A good comparison must include current price, projected starts, yellow-card risk, opportunity cost and the next three fixtures, rather than awarding the recommendation to the latest scorer.