The short answer
Alexander Isak is the safer Liverpool buy. Cody Gakpo can be the better structural transfer if midfield is the position you need to fix.
Both delivered against Ipswich in GW3: Isak scored twice and Gakpo assisted both goals. Liverpool now host Fulham.
Isak vs Gakpo: quick comparison
| Factor | Alexander Isak | Cody Gakpo |
|---|---|---|
| FPL position | Forward | Midfielder |
| GW3 return | Two goals | Two assists |
| Main appeal | Central scoring role | Midfield access to Liverpool attack |
| Minutes confidence | Higher | More rotation concern |
| Rotation issue | Lower | Barcola adds competition |
| Current price signal | Rose to £9.1m on 8 Sep | £7.2m after recent rise |
| Best for | Managers fixing a forward slot | Managers fixing midfield |
Why Isak is safer
Isak's role is straightforward: he is Liverpool's central goalscorer. Two goals at Ipswich increase confidence without changing the basic reason to own him.
Why Gakpo remains attractive
Gakpo created both Isak goals at Ipswich. His advantage is structural: managers can access Liverpool's attack from midfield.
The concern is minutes. Bradley Barcola is now part of Liverpool's wide rotation.
Which transfer gives you the better team?
Compare Isak + your current midfielder against Gakpo + your current forward.
The stronger pair is the real decision.
Use OneFPL Player Lab and Transfer Planner to test both structures.
OneFPL verdict
Isak = safer. Gakpo = cheaper midfield route with more rotation risk.
FAQ
Is Isak better than Gakpo in FPL?
Isak currently has the safer role. Gakpo can still be the better transfer if your midfield needs upgrading.
Should I buy Gakpo after two assists?
He is a strong option, but Barcola's arrival increases long-term rotation risk.
Can I own Isak and Gakpo together?
Yes, if your wider squad remains balanced.
Sources
- Liverpool FC — Ipswich 0-2 Liverpool
- Fantasy Premier League price data
- OneFPL Liverpool GW4 guide
OneFPL analysis. OneFPL is an independent Fantasy Premier League companion and is not affiliated with, endorsed by or connected to the Premier League or Fantasy Premier League.
Was this useful?